Mintzberg believes that it is only the manager that has current and full information to make a set of decisions associating the organizations work and determines their strategies Mintzberg, Unlike Fayol suggesting what managers should do Mintzberg identified ten roles in which he believed a manager should undertake in order to be successful within their managerial position. He stressed that the number of principles, however, were non-exhaustive and that they are flexible and adaptable to every need Fayol , Brodie , in Fells, , pg. Henry Mintzberg specifically for you. Want us to write one just for you? As in the case just illustrated the function of the task is more subjective as opposed to the role undertaken to carry out the task.

As he was a manager himself, or in other words an administrator, he devoted his work to the latter activity, management. However in Page 1 of 6. Of course they all had their good reasons for not delegating their work. The Nature of Managerial Work. Your time is important. Henry Mintzberg is an internationally renowned academic and author on business and management with over articles and thirteen books written. Risk Management Strategies Essay.

French managerial scholar Minhzberg Fayol identified the roles of a successful manager. The concept of managerial style, attempts to combine the two function and role theories.

fayol vs mintzberg essay

We use cookies to give you the best experience possible. Individuals, Groups and Organisation. The fact in this case is that managers prefer to get their information through telephone calls or meetings. The Structuring of Organizations. Ezsay than that, the rational-functional perspective of management and the social-functional perspective will also be discussed in this essay.

Also, the fact that the training is actually following a plan proves that the planning function is also involved.

Henri Fayol vs. Henry Mintzberg | Free Essays –

And applying them to real life words – 4 pages manager we can learn that they are carried out continually in society and it is in fact managers that implement them. Duties that are interpersonal may require little communication and no serious decision making.


Through esday years that led on to this Fayol then developed his 14 principles of management which he considered to be the most important.

His ten roles were then condensed into three different roles, which are, interpersonal, informational and decisional roles – such as leader, entrepreneur, resource allocator and spokesman.

The Roots of Modern Management Principals words – 10 pages management.

Towards a revival of the principles of management. Hi there, would you like to get eesay a paper? Therefore one cannot really say esxay his ideas came out of the blue, especially in a time where only little research about management processes has already been published. Fayol identifies five elements of management- planning, organising, co-ordinating, commanding and controlling all of which he believed were necessary to facilitate the management process.

Mintzberg, There are anyhow two points one can hold against him:. But in order to qualify the argument: Mintzberg believes that it is only the manager that has va and full information to make a set of decisions associating the organizations work and determines their strategies Mintzberg, The 3 interpersonal roles are; the figurehead which helps reinforce what the company stands for and reinforces the organisational culture, the leader who provide their employees with a sense of mission and the liaison who mixes with others outside the business to represent the needs of their group.

9 Principles of Management: Henry Mintzberg vs Henry Fayol

Hence, a manager enacting the entrepreneur role may prefer to search for long-term opportunities or current opportunities. An updated typology of management skills, Management Decision, 42 10 In fact, with his managerial roles Mintzberg has tried to make a connection between mangagerial functions as found by Fayol and the mangerial behaviour he observed himself.


Fayol suggested that these principles should be used by people within managerial positions when involved in their own management processes. Mintzberg proposes an alternative classical view on management. Mintzberg, having done all the studies on muntzberg and actually seeing what they do in their day to day workings has given him a better idea of fayo the mihtzberg of the manager actually entails.

Mintzberg argues that this role has four major working tasks which are the manager must be an entrepreneurhe must allocate resourcesnegotiateand a disturbance handler meaning that the manager should be in change of unexpected conditions and be able to solve them Mintzberg, And while Mintzberg also provides a fair insight into the area of contemporary management, he still misses the point about effectiveness.

Get esasy paper now.

Management: Fayol Vs Mintzberg Essay – Words – BrightKite

Henri Fayol and Henry Mintzberg. Henry Mintzberg vs Henry Fayol. If we can find lots of similarities then we can conclude that Fayol. Henry Mintzberg believes that the five functions of management do not really tell us much about what a manager actually does but at best paint a vague picture of what objectives managers have when they work.

Henri Fayol vs. Henry Mintzberg

Brooks, Fayol himself mintzbedg that the number of principles was non-exhaustive. Preferred being what a manager may prefer to do, and enacted being what a manager is forced to do, depending on situational demands and limits.

fayol vs mintzberg essay

These principles are what he sees as the basis of all management situations no matter the organization.